| Player | Football League | |
|---|---|---|
| Goals | Apps | |
| Luther Blissett | 148 | 415 |
| Tommy Barnett | 144 | 395 |
| Troy Deeney | 131 | 389 |
| Ross Anthony Jenkins | 118 | 339 |
| Cliff Holton | 96 | 144 |
| Taffy Davies | 69 | 283 |
| Maurice Cook | 68 | 208 |
| Billy Lane | 68 | 124 |
| George James | 67 | 83 |
| Frank McPherson | 67 | 94 |
| Fred Pagnam | 67 | 144 |
| Heidar Helguson | 66 | 203 |
| John Barnes | 65 | 233 |
| Tommy Smith | 60 | 273 |
| Tommy Mooney | 58 | 250 |
| George Harris | 55 | 163 |
| Paul Wilkinson | 51 | 138 |
| Stewart Scullion | 49 | 312 |
| Terry Garbett | 46 | 200 |
| Keith Mercer | 46 | 134 |
| Gary Porter | 46 | 400 |